How to Fix Spotify’s Shuffle Mode (And Why It Feels Broken)

How to Fix Spotify’s Shuffle Mode (And Why It Feels Broken)

by

In 2025, Spotify remains a powerhouse for music lovers, offering access to over 100 million tracks. But despite its advanced algorithms, the shuffle feature often feels broken—repeating songs, favoring certain artists, or playing the same order repeatedly. Let’s explore why this happens and how to fix it.

Why Spotify’s Shuffle Feels “Off”

  1. Algorithmic Bias: Spotify’s shuffle isn’t purely random. It considers your listening habits, playlist engagement, and even skips, which can lead to repetitive patterns.
  2. Playlist Size: Large playlists (1,000+ songs) make it harder for the algorithm to distribute tracks evenly.
  3. Cache Issues: Corrupted local data can cause glitches in playback order.
  4. Offline Mode Limitations: Downloaded playlists shuffle less effectively due to cached data constraints.
  5. Crossfade/Smart Shuffle Conflicts: Features like crossfade or the newer Smart Shuffle (which adds recommended songs) can disrupt traditional shuffling.

How to Fix Spotify Shuffle: 2025 Solutions

1. Use Spotify’s Smart Shuffle (For Fresh Mixes)

Spotify’s Smart Shuffle (released in 2023) adds algorithmically picked songs to your playlist while shuffling.

  • Steps:
  • Open your playlist.
  • Tap the shuffle icon twice (first to enable shuffle, second to activate Smart Shuffle).
  • Look for the “+ Recommended” badge to confirm it’s on.

Note: This works best for playlists with 50+ songs. Disable it if you want a purely random shuffle.

2. Disable Crossfade & Volume Normalization

These features can interfere with seamless shuffling:

  • On Mobile/Desktop:
  • Go to Settings → Playback.
  • Toggle off Crossfade and Volume Normalization.

3. Clear Cache (Fix Glitches)Mobile:

  • Settings → Storage → Clear Cache.
    Desktop:
  • Settings → Advanced Settings → Delete Cache.

4. Use a “True Shuffle” Workaround

Spotify’s shuffle isn’t random, but you can force it:

  • On Desktop:
  1. Sort your playlist by song title (A→Z).
  2. Shuffle and play. This disrupts the algorithm’s default order.
  • On Mobile:
  • Create a duplicate playlist and shuffle the copy.

5. Try Third-Party Tools (With Caution)

Apps like Skiley or Spotify Randomizer offer better shuffle control:

  1. Grant limited playlist access (no full account permissions).
  2. Generate a shuffled version of your playlist.

⚠️ Avoid tools requesting full account access—stick to reputable services.

Why Can’t I Shuffle Specific Albums/Artists?

  • Shuffling an Artist’s Discography: Tap the Shuffle button on an artist’s profile.
  • Shuffling Albums: Open the album → Tap the Shuffle icon.
  • Pro Tip: Use the Enhance feature on playlists to mix in similar tracks.

FAQs

Q: Why does shuffle repeat songs?

A: Smaller playlists and algorithmic bias cause repetition. Try adding 50+ songs or using Smart Shuffle.

Q: Can I prioritize certain songs?

A: No, but Spotify’s “Sort by Most Played” in playlist settings indirectly surfaces favorites.

Q: Does offline mode affect shuffle?

A: Yes. Re-download playlists or toggle offline mode to reset the cache.

Q: Is “True Random Shuffle” possible?

A: Not natively. Use third-party tools or manual workarounds (see above).

Final Tips

  • Update the App: Ensure you’re on the latest version (shuffle improvements are ongoing).
  • Shorten Playlists: Split large playlists into smaller, themed ones (e.g., “Workout 1,” “Workout 2”).
  • Feedback to Spotify: Use the app’s Help → Submit Feedback to report issues.

Conclusion

While Spotify’s shuffle isn’t perfect, understanding its quirks and using modern fixes—like Smart Shuffle, cache resets, and third-party tools—can transform your listening experience. Stay updated, experiment with workarounds, and keep your playlists fresh!

This revision reflects Spotify’s current features (e.g., Smart Shuffle), addresses algorithmic biases, and offers actionable 2025 solutions. Let me know if you’d like to refine specific sections! 🎧

Leave a Comment